Grassroots in Nebraska

Working towards Constitutional, limited government

  • Home
  • About
    • About GiN
    • Principles
    • Operating Philosophy
    • Policies
  • Elections
    • Election 2016
    • Election 2014
    • Election 2012
    • Election 2010
    • Local Elections
    • Sample Ballots
  • Local
    • City of Lincoln
    • Lancaster County
  • State
    • Your Representatives
    • Governor
    • NE Unicameral
  • Federal
  • Contact
    • Subscribe
    • Tip Submissions
You are here: Home / Local / City of Lincoln / Mayor Beutler: Crafty Politician, Walter Mitty, or Just Going Rogue?

Mayor Beutler: Crafty Politician, Walter Mitty, or Just Going Rogue?

Originally published November 12, 2010, By Shelli Dawdy. Updated November 12, 2010. 2 Comments

By Shelli Dawdy

As I noted yesterday, Lincoln Mayor Chris Beutler held a press conference earlier this week wherein he announced a methane gas drilling project that was just beginning at the Bluffs Road facility.

The City’s Public Works department had commenced drilling 60+ wells and installing a piping system to capture methane gas from the dump site. Plans included using the methane gas to generate electricity.

While there were a few things that raised my eyebrows about the press conference, I knew I needed further information before forming an opinion. There were a couple of statements by Mayor Beutler that bothered me immediately, however, and one of them was his mention that he had decided that Lincoln would voluntarily lower its emissions.

What really sent up red flags for me in watching the report on Lincoln’s KLKN-TV was the Public Works Director’s assertion that the costs of the methane capture system installation would be more than repaid from the income generated by the carbon credit income.

As I noted in the previous article, it is very puzzling that any elected official would be mentioning carbon credits since the federal legislation commonly known as “Cap & Trade” had failed to move through the legislative process after passing out of the House of Representatives in June 2009. Absent a national system of carbon credits, how can it be that the City of Lincoln would be engaging in a carbon exchange?

There are a few explanations, all falling squarely within a category that is negative, and the only differences are matters of degree.

Possible scenarios:

  1. The Mayor is playing pure politics by touting the potential carbon credit income.
  2. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has notified municipal governments that they are implementing a carbon cap and credit system via their regulating authority and citizens have not yet been made aware of this fact.
  3. The Mayor has decided that Lincoln, Nebraska will participate in some kind of carbon exchange.

There may well be additional scenarios which I am not considering. If anyone reading this has any others, I invite you to leave a comment.

In scenario #1 our Mayor would simply be using language familiar to his “base”, the extreme left that is “all-in” for the radical environmental agenda. Perhaps all of these folks, including the Mayor, have high hopes that some future legislation will be passed to revive their dreams. The Mayor has made a very public commitment to this agenda, having already stated repeatedly that he wants Lincoln to be a model “green capital city of the plains“. Further, he suffered some embarrassment not all that long ago when his proposed budget include the cutting the of City Forester position. As I pointed out in an article at the end of August; how can the “Cleaner Greener Lincoln” guy be a hypocrite and fire the tree supervisor?

In scenario #2, our Mayor would simply be quietly implementing federal regulations over which he has little control. It is a fact that the EPA declared carbon dioxide emissions a danger to public health in December of 2009. If that is the case, Lincoln would be at the leading edge of the implementation. This explanation doesn’t totally fit, however, since the implementation as explained previously, seemed to involve only higher-level emitters, and does not appear to include an exchange as did the Cap & Trade legislation.

Scenario #3 requires that the City of Lincoln would be participating in some kind of global climate exchange. There are several independent global climate exchanges. Some brokers of these services do work with government entities. It cannot be that the City would participate in an American exchange, as the only one that existed, the Chicago Climate Exchange recently collapsed.

All of these scenarios are troubling, of course, with #1 be very distasteful, but damaging only to Mayor Beutler’s reputation in the end. EPA implementation-by-stealth of cap & trade regulations (#2) is a real problem that we can hope will be addressed in the upcoming session of Congress, any one of the pending lawsuits now working their way through the legal system, or one can also hope, through states asserting sovereignty.

If the Mayor and Public Works Director have determined there is a boon of revenue to be generated through the sale of carbon credits and therefore the City should participate in an global carbon exchange, of course those of us who live, work, and pay taxes in Lincoln would sure like to know just where our dear Mayor got the idea he could do so arbitrarily.

Based on information to date, there was no authorizing vote by our City Council for such an action. Reportedly, the methane gas project was a simple line item in the City’s most recent budget, paid for by stimulus dollars (of course…what else?). There was no discussion of a carbon credit exchange participation.

Besides the necessary authorization according in our city for such participation, residents and taxpayers would likely want to know what such participation would entail. Would the legally binding nature of such an endeavor mean that carbon emission of all kinds within the City of Lincoln would fall under the guidelines?

Setting aside these troubling questions for the moment, let us presume Lincoln would participate in a carbon exchange. Would it be a financial windfall? The answer comes in the form of a question, at least to start: Why did the Chicago Climate Exchange fail?

The obvious answer is that the carbon exchange market itself is collapsing. Carbon credits on the CCX, having reached a peak price of $7.50 per ton in 2008, dropped to a low of $.10 per ton in August, and were still falling.

As “The Great Collapse of the Chicago Climate Exchange” article reports, the revelation of the “Climategate” scandal and other events mean there is no real market for carbon credits in the United States. While, as noted above, there are other carbon exchanges in the world, the most active are required by law.

We continue to research the facts on the methane drilling project and to just what, precisely, the Public Works Director referred when he mentioned carbon credits. We will ultimately answer the following question as well…Does Mayor Beutler have delusions of grandeur ala Walter Mitty, is he simply a crafty politician, or has he decided to “go rogue”?

Share this article:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Google
  • More
  • Tumblr
  • Reddit
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn

Filed Under: City of Lincoln, Featured, Local Tagged With: bluffs road lanfill, cap & tax, cap & trade, cap and tax, cap and trade, carbon caps, carbon credit exchange, carbon credits, carbon dioxide, carbon emissions, chicago climate exchange, chris beutler, city council, city council meeting, city forestor, City of Lincoln, city regulations, co2 emissions, co2 pollutant, collapse carbon credit exchange, electricity, environmental protection agency, epa, epa declaration carbon, going rogue, lincoln nebraska, lincoln public works director, mayor chris beutler, mayor's office, methane gas capture, politicians, public works, secret life of walter mitty, stimulus funds, Sustainable Development

Comments

  1. Charlotte Ralston says

    January 11, 2011 at 5:39 am

    Shelli,
    This might explain the carbon credit concerns.
    http://www.sustainablecitynetwork.com/topic_channels/environmental/article_0c8e87f2-02e8-11e0-96b8-00127992bc8b.html
    Lincoln and Omaha are now members of the ICLEI – look up that website to learn more.
    Sorry I couldn’t get to your meeting tonight, hope it went well.

    Reply
    • Shelli DawdyStubborn_Facts says

      January 17, 2011 at 11:52 pm

      Charlotte,
      Thank you for the information and I appreciate this particular link as it is one I don’t believe we’ve seen as of yet. Sustainable Development is an issue we have been looking into for quite some time and we have put out a number of articles about it on our site and there will be more to come. Since the level of activity just keeps increasing, particularly here in Lincoln and over in Omaha, including, as you mention, the City of Lincoln joining ICLEI.

      As of right now, however, there seems to be no logical explanation available for either Mayor Beutler’s or Milo Mumgaard’s statements regarding carbon credits, even accounting for the membership in ICLEI. There is no carbon credit exchange available within the US as the only one in existence is now defunct. Either it is pure rhetoric or there is an apparent intent to join an international carbon credit exchange.

      Obviously, it is disturbing either way; knowingly making erroneous statements or an intent to join in on an international program.

      Clearly this is an issue that we are all concerned about and of course, affects everyone in Lincoln.

      Again, we appreciate the link and interest in what we’re doing,

      Shelli

      Reply
You are here: Home / Local / City of Lincoln / Mayor Beutler: Crafty Politician, Walter Mitty, or Just Going Rogue?

We welcome civil comments, discussion and debate: Cancel reply

We're glad you've chosen to join the discussion. All comments are moderated according to our official commenting policy.

If you wish to format your comment a bit, simply highlight text, then click the appropriate button. (b = bold, i = italics)

Latest

NE Medicaid Expansion:  Birth of an Entitlement Nation

NE Medicaid Expansion: Birth of an Entitlement Nation

The purpose of this article is to sketch a short history of Medicaid.  … Read full article...

NE Medicaid Expansion:  The Race is On (AGAIN)

NE Medicaid Expansion: The Race is On (AGAIN)

Back on January 17, 2013, I published an article here at the GiN website … Read full article...

A Tribute to GiN Founder Shelli J. Dawdy

A Tribute to GiN Founder Shelli J. Dawdy

We could begin this eulogy with a recitation of the usual facts and statistics, … Read full article...

Why the Electoral College?  Because State and Regional Diversity Matters.

Why the Electoral College? Because State and Regional Diversity Matters.

Where you live, your day-to-day experience gained through interacting with your … Read full article...

VOTE!  It’s Weasel-Stomping Day!

VOTE! It’s Weasel-Stomping Day!

For those of you who have lost your sense of humor during this interminable … Read full article...

What’s Wrong With the Electoral College?

What’s Wrong With the Electoral College?

During my lifetime, I've heard more criticisms of the Electoral College than … Read full article...

Submit News Tips

If you have information about an important issue or event that you believe demands further scrutiny, please visit our Tips Submission page.

Unlocking Solutions

"...in our system it is often more
important HOW we do something than what we do. Priorities and policies (and presidents) change. We cannot change the system upon which we all depend for our rights and representation."

~ Jonathan Turley, Professor of Public Interest Law, Testimony before the Committee on the Judiciary, February 26, 2014
Read more...

Subscribe to new articles by Email!

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Top Articles – All Time

GiN Response to Presidential Popular Vote Advocate

Presidential Election 2012 Electoral College Maps as of October 9, 2012

This most read article is an energetic response to the well-funded, organized effort to eliminate the Electoral College.

TransCanada Trojan Horse: Keystone XL Pipeline Will Increase Gas Prices

TransCanada Trojan Horse: Keystone XL Pipeline Will Increase Gas Prices

We're sure this article has been so well read because it is decidedly unique. If you want a different perspective on the Keystone Pipeline, this is a good place to start.

Dr. Benjamin Carson - Speaking Truth to Power

This popular article was written in 2013, well before voters began to take an interest in the good doctor. It was inspired by a reading of Dr. Carson's book.

Photo of Dr. Benjamin Carson

A Republic If You Can Keep It

Painting of Benjamin Franklin

For the past five years and counting, we've found the continued popularity of this article a source of hope. At the very least, a lot of people are curious about this historical incident.

Archives

SO, we had a 10th Amendment resolution, huh?

And how's that working out for us?
GiN's Nullification Series provides a hint:
  1. Nullification Not the Answer for Health Care
  2. History Has Proven Nullification a Failure: Just Look at REAL ID
  3. Nullification Measures Not Stopping Health Care Implementation (Think Idaho)
  4. Nullification: Are State Level Officials Really Opposed to Federal Encroachment?

Health Care Archive

GiN health care graphic
  • Health Care Law Achilles Heel? A Growing Legal Morass
  • Money For Nothing and Health Care For Free
  • Families Need Medicaid Like Fish Need Bicycles

Search the GiN site

Some Vintage GiN

Governor Heineman Really Liked Purple People Before They Were “Cool”

A Republic If You Can Keep It

Ever-Expanding Welfare: He May Be My Brother, But He's Getting Heavy

47% of Nebraska Births Paid for By the State: Is that Good?

Also of Possible Interest

NE Medicaid Expansion: Birth of an Entitlement Nation

The purpose of this article is to sketch a short history of Medicaid.  Why? "We study the past to understand the present; we understand the present to guide the future."     -- … [Read More...]

NE Medicaid Expansion: The Race is On (AGAIN)

Back on January 17, 2013, I published an article here at the GiN website entitled "NE Medicaid Expansion: The Race is On."  I followed up with an entire series of articles … [Read More...]

Subscribe: New Articles Delivered By Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Quoteworthy

"Nothing is easier than spending the public money. It does not appear to belong to anybody. The temptation is overwhelming to bestow it on somebody."

~ Calvin Coolidge, Fourth Annual Message, December 7, 1926

Copyright© 2009–2018 · Grassroots in Nebraska · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Jovian Limited

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.